Every successful California remodel has a secret ingredient that goes beyond beautiful design and quality craftsmanship. It’s called Title 24, the state’s set of energy efficiency standards. While it might seem like just another line item in the building code, it’s actually a roadmap to creating a home that’s more comfortable, cheaper to run, and kinder to the environment. Getting it right is non-negotiable for avoiding permit delays and costly rework. This guide will break down the essentials, showing you how achieving title 24 compliance is one of the smartest investments you can make in your property’s long-term value and your own daily comfort.
Key Takeaways
- Think of Title 24 as a Blueprint for a Better Home: While compliance is necessary to avoid permit delays and failed inspections, its main purpose is to create a more comfortable and cost-efficient home. The required upgrades in insulation, windows, and systems directly lead to lower monthly utility bills.
- Focus on Your Home’s Core Energy Systems: Title 24 compliance centers on the key components that impact energy use. Be prepared for specific requirements for your HVAC system, water heater, lighting, and kitchen appliances, as these are critical for meeting the state’s efficiency standards.
- Your Contractor’s Expertise is Non-Negotiable: You don’t need to master the energy code, but your contractor does. Hiring a team with deep, current knowledge of Title 24 is the single most important step to ensure your project’s paperwork is handled correctly and your renovation proceeds without costly setbacks.
What Is Title 24?
If you’re planning a remodel in California, you’ll quickly hear about “Title 24.” It might sound like technical jargon, but it’s a crucial part of any home project in the state. Think of it as California’s rulebook for making sure homes are energy-efficient, comfortable, and environmentally friendly. Understanding the basics will help you plan a smoother, more successful renovation that not only looks great but also performs beautifully for years to come.
California’s Energy Efficiency Code Explained
So, what exactly is it? Title 24, Part 6, is California’s official Building Energy Efficiency Standards. Its main goal is simple: to cut down on wasteful energy use in both new and existing buildings. The code is updated every few years to include new technologies and building methods, making it a constantly evolving roadmap for energy-efficient construction. For your remodel, this means any changes you make—from new windows to an updated HVAC system—need to meet these specific energy-saving requirements.
Key Areas Your Remodel Needs to Cover
Ignoring Title 24 isn’t an option. Non-compliance can get your building permits denied or cause you to fail inspections, bringing your entire major renovation to a halt. To stay on track, you’ll need to pay close attention to a few key areas. This typically includes the quality and installation of your insulation, the efficiency of your windows and doors, the performance of your heating and cooling systems, and the type of lighting you install. For larger projects, it might even involve rules around solar energy. Getting these details right from the start is essential for a project that runs smoothly.
Why Does Title 24 Matter for Your Remodel?
Title 24 might sound like just another line item on a long list of building codes, but it’s one of the most important regulations for any California homeowner to understand. It’s California’s Building Energy Efficiency Standards, and it’s designed to ensure that homes—both new and remodeled—are built to conserve energy and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. For your remodel, this isn’t just about checking a box for the city inspector. It’s about creating a home that’s more comfortable, affordable to run, and kinder to the environment.
Following Title 24 guidelines directly impacts your wallet by lowering your monthly utility bills. It also plays a huge role in the state’s environmental goals, making your home part of a larger effort to build a sustainable future. Most importantly for your project’s timeline and budget, compliance is non-negotiable. Failing to meet these standards can bring your entire renovation to a grinding halt with permit denials and costly fixes. Understanding why Title 24 matters is the first step toward a smoother, smarter, and more successful remodel.
Save Money and Energy
Let’s talk about the long-term win. Complying with Title 24 means installing energy-efficient features like better insulation, high-performance windows, and modern HVAC systems. While some of these materials might have a slightly higher upfront cost, they pay for themselves over time. Think lower heating and cooling bills every single month. An energy-efficient home is simply less expensive to operate, leaving more money in your pocket for the things you actually enjoy. It’s a smart investment that adds lasting value to your property and makes your home more comfortable year-round.
Protect the Environment
Your remodel is part of a bigger picture. California’s Title 24 standards are some of the most progressive in the country for a reason—they’re a key part of the state’s plan to reduce energy consumption. As this evolving roadmap for energy efficiency gets updated, it incorporates new technologies to push for even greater savings. By following these guidelines, you’re doing more than just upgrading your space. You’re contributing to a statewide effort to conserve natural resources and lower our collective carbon footprint, helping to keep California beautiful for generations to come.
Stay Compliant and Avoid Permit Issues
This is where Title 24 gets very real for your project timeline. Local building departments will not approve your permits if your plans don’t meet Title 24 requirements. Non-compliance can lead to failed inspections, fines, and significant delays that throw your entire major renovation off schedule. Imagine having to tear out newly installed work because it doesn’t meet code—it’s a costly and frustrating setback. Working with an experienced team ensures your plans are compliant from day one, so you can avoid the administrative headaches and keep your project moving forward smoothly.
What Are the Main Title 24 Requirements?
When you’re planning a remodel, Title 24 can feel like a long list of complicated rules. But at its core, it’s all about making your home more comfortable and energy-efficient. Think of it as a set of guidelines that ensures your updated space uses energy smartly, from the attic to the foundation. The requirements touch on several key areas of your home, working together to create a system that saves energy and lowers your utility bills. Whether you’re planning a full home remodel or focusing on a single room, understanding these main components is the first step toward a smooth, compliant, and successful project. Let’s walk through the five main areas you’ll need to address.
Insulation and Air Sealing
One of the biggest ways a home loses energy is through poor insulation and tiny air leaks. Title 24 sets specific standards for insulation in your walls, ceilings, and floors to keep your home warm in the winter and cool in the summer. It’s not just about adding pink fluff in the attic; it’s about using the right type and amount of insulation. Equally important is air sealing—finding and closing all the little gaps and cracks that let conditioned air escape. Failing to meet these standards can cause your project to fail inspection, leading to frustrating and costly delays. Proper insulation and air sealing are foundational for an energy-efficient home.
Heating and Cooling Systems (HVAC)
Your heating and air conditioning system is a major energy user, so it’s a key focus of Title 24. The code requires high-efficiency HVAC units that don’t have to work as hard to keep you comfortable. It also looks at the entire system, including tightly sealed ductwork to prevent air loss. A big part of the modern HVAC requirements is the use of smart thermostats. These devices are designed to adjust to energy demands, helping you use energy only when you need it. Upgrading your HVAC system during a remodel ensures it not only meets code but also performs efficiently for years to come.
Efficient Lighting
Gone are the days of inefficient incandescent bulbs. Title 24 requires high-efficacy lighting throughout your home, which usually means using LEDs. These lights use a fraction of the energy and last much longer. The rules also extend to lighting controls. For example, in a kitchen remodel, you’ll likely need dimmers or vacancy sensors that automatically turn lights off when a room is empty. The same goes for bathrooms, where these controls add convenience and ensure you’re not wasting electricity. It’s a simple change that makes a big difference in your home’s overall energy consumption.
High-Performance Windows and Doors
Windows and doors are essentially holes in your home’s insulated barrier, so Title 24 has strict rules to make sure they perform well. The code focuses on two key metrics: U-factor and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC). In simple terms, U-factor measures how well a window insulates, while SHGC measures how much heat from the sun it blocks. The right Title 24 windows will help maintain a stable indoor temperature without overworking your HVAC system. Choosing high-performance windows and doors is a smart investment that pays off in both comfort and energy savings.
Solar Power Rules
You’ve probably heard that California requires solar panels on new homes, and this rule is part of Title 24. While it primarily applies to new construction, it can also affect major renovations and additions, like building an ADU. The goal is to have homes generate some of their own clean energy, reducing their reliance on the power grid. The solar mandate offers some flexibility in how you meet the requirement, but it’s an important factor to consider in the early planning stages of a large-scale project. It’s a forward-thinking rule that helps make California’s homes more sustainable.
How Do Title 24 Updates Affect You?
Title 24 isn’t a one-and-done set of rules. It’s a living document that evolves to keep pace with technology and California’s ambitious energy goals. For homeowners, this means the requirements for a kitchen remodel today might be different from what they were just a few years ago. Understanding how these updates work is key to planning a smooth and successful project. Instead of seeing them as hurdles, think of them as a roadmap to a more efficient, comfortable, and valuable home. Staying aware of these changes helps you plan your budget and timeline accurately, ensuring there are no surprises along the way.
The Three-Year Update Cycle
California’s energy code is updated on a three-year cycle to ensure our homes are as efficient as possible. Every update tightens the requirements, incorporating new technologies and building strategies that have proven effective. This regular refresh means the standards for things like insulation, window performance, and lighting are always improving. What this means for you is that you can’t assume the rules from a past project will apply to your current one. A contractor who stays on top of these changes is essential, as they’ll know exactly which version of the code applies to your project and how to meet its specific demands.
How Changes Can Impact Your Project
Falling behind on the latest Title 24 updates can bring your remodel to a screeching halt. Non-compliance can lead to significant penalties and project delays. For instance, your building permits may be denied, forcing you and your team to redesign parts of your project to meet the new standards. This doesn’t just add time; it adds unexpected costs. Imagine having your heart set on a specific type of window or lighting fixture, only to find out it doesn’t meet the current code. A knowledgeable contractor can guide you through a major renovation and help you select compliant materials from the start, saving you from headaches and budget overruns.
Keeping Up with the Latest Rules
While the idea of constantly changing regulations might seem daunting, you don’t have to become a Title 24 expert yourself. The key is to work with a team that already is. Recognizing challenges early allows you to prepare and minimize issues related to code conflicts and administrative delays. An experienced contractor will review your plans against the most current standards before you even apply for a permit. They’ll handle the complex paperwork and ensure every detail, from your HVAC system to your bathroom ventilation, is up to code. This proactive approach is the secret to keeping your project on track and stress-free.
What Makes Title 24 Compliance Tricky?
While the goal of Title 24 is straightforward—to make California homes more energy-efficient—the path to compliance can feel like a maze. For homeowners planning a remodel, it introduces a layer of technical requirements that go far beyond choosing paint colors and cabinet styles. The code is detailed, frequently updated, and leaves very little room for error.
The biggest hurdles often come from the sheer volume of rules, the specific documentation required, and the need to coordinate everything perfectly to keep your project on track. Understanding these challenges from the start is the best way to prepare for a smooth and successful renovation. Let’s break down the most common pain points you might encounter.
Complex Rules and Paperwork
Let’s be honest: most of us aren’t energy code experts. The Title 24 standards are dense and technical, covering everything from the U-factor of your windows to the efficiency of your water heater. On top of understanding the rules, you have to prove compliance through specific forms and calculations. If this paperwork isn’t filled out perfectly, you can face serious setbacks. Local building departments will not approve a permit without correct and complete Title 24 documentation, which can stop your full house renovation before it even begins.
Budgeting for Compliance Costs
Meeting Title 24 standards often requires investing in higher-performance materials and systems, which can impact your overall budget. Energy-efficient windows, upgraded insulation, and high-efficiency HVAC systems typically have a higher upfront cost than their standard counterparts. While these upgrades save you money on utility bills over time, they are a necessary expense you must account for in your initial remodeling budget. Thinking through these costs early on helps you plan a realistic budget and avoid surprises down the road.
Avoiding Permit Delays
Nothing stalls a project faster than a permit rejection. Your local building department will review your plans to ensure every aspect of your remodel meets code, and Title 24 is a major part of that inspection. If your plans or compliance documents have errors, your permit application will be sent back for corrections, adding weeks or even months to your timeline. Recognizing these potential administrative hurdles early allows you to prepare properly and minimize delays, ensuring your kitchen remodeling project starts on schedule.
Finding the Right Experts
Successfully meeting Title 24 requirements isn’t a DIY job. It demands a deep understanding of building science, energy modeling software, and local regulations. This is why it’s so important to work with knowledgeable professionals who live and breathe these complexities. An experienced contractor will not only design a compliant project but will also handle the calculations and paperwork correctly. They act as your guide, ensuring every part of your project—from the roofing to the foundation—is up to code.
How to Meet Title 24 Standards
Meeting California’s energy standards might seem like a huge task, but it’s entirely manageable with the right approach. The key is to be proactive and work with professionals who understand the rules inside and out. By planning ahead, you can ensure your project runs smoothly, stays on budget, and results in a beautiful, energy-efficient home. Here are four practical steps you can take to make sure your remodel is fully compliant.
Partner with an Experienced Contractor
You don’t have to become a Title 24 expert overnight—that’s what your contractor is for. In most home renovations, your contractor is the one who handles the permits. That’s why it’s so important to partner with a team that is deeply familiar with California’s energy codes. An experienced contractor will guide you through the requirements for your specific project, whether it’s a kitchen remodel or a full-house renovation. They can recommend compliant materials, appliances, and building techniques from the very beginning, saving you from costly surprises and delays down the road. Think of them as your compliance co-pilot.
Start with a Pre-Project Assessment
Before you even think about swinging a hammer, a pre-project assessment can be a game-changer. This early step helps identify any potential compliance issues before they become real problems. A thorough assessment will look at your home’s current state and your remodeling plans to flag areas that might conflict with Title 24 or local zoning regulations. This proactive check allows you and your contractor to adjust the design and plan for any necessary upgrades, ensuring quality control and a much smoother permit process. It’s all about catching things early to keep your project on track.
Prescriptive vs. Performance: What’s the Difference?
When it comes to proving Title 24 compliance, there are two main paths: prescriptive and performance. The prescriptive approach is like a checklist—you simply use pre-approved materials and installation methods outlined in the code. It’s straightforward and works well for smaller projects. The performance approach is more flexible and uses energy modeling software to show that your custom design meets the overall energy efficiency standard, even if it doesn’t follow the exact prescriptive checklist. Understanding the difference is key, as non-compliance can lead to denied permits and major project delays. Your contractor can help you decide which path makes the most sense for your major renovation.
Keep Your Paperwork in Order
A successful remodel involves a lot of paperwork, and staying organized is one of the best things you can do for a stress-free experience. From design plans and energy calculations to permit applications and inspection reports, keeping all your documents in one place is vital. Recognizing potential permit challenges early on allows you to prepare and minimize complications. A well-organized file makes it easier for you and your contractor to communicate with building officials and prove compliance at every stage. Your contractor should help manage this, but keeping your own copies is always a smart move.
How Title 24 Applies to Kitchen and Bath Remodels
Kitchens and bathrooms are the heart of a home, but they’re also major hubs for energy and water use. That’s why Title 24 has specific rules for these spaces. When you’re planning a kitchen remodel, you’re not just thinking about new cabinets and countertops; you’re also upgrading the systems that make the room work. The same goes for a bathroom renovation.
These regulations cover everything from the appliances you choose to the air you breathe. The goal is to make sure your newly updated rooms are as efficient and healthy as they are beautiful. While it might sound like another layer of rules to follow, these requirements are designed to give you a better-performing home. Think lower utility bills, improved air quality, and a more comfortable living environment. Let’s look at the three key areas where Title 24 will show up in your kitchen and bath projects: appliances, water heating, and ventilation.
Efficient Kitchen Appliances
When it’s time to pick out new appliances, Title 24 requires that they meet certain energy efficiency standards. This applies to your refrigerator, dishwasher, and oven. Essentially, any new appliance you install must be certified to consume less energy and water. The easiest way to spot a compliant product is to look for the ENERGY STAR label, which is a clear indicator that it meets or exceeds federal efficiency guidelines.
While this might narrow your choices slightly, it’s a huge win for your wallet in the long run. Energy-efficient appliances can significantly reduce your monthly utility bills. A knowledgeable contractor can guide you toward models that not only fit your design vision but also meet California’s standards, ensuring your beautiful new kitchen is also a smart, high-performing one.
Water Heaters in the Bathroom
Hot water is a bathroom essential, and Title 24 has rules to make sure it’s delivered efficiently. The code mandates that any new water heater installed in your home must meet specific efficiency ratings. This applies whether you choose a traditional tank-style heater or a modern tankless one. The key metric here is the energy factor (EF) rating, which measures how efficiently the unit converts energy into hot water.
Your contractor will help you select a water heater with a compliant EF rating that’s properly sized for your family’s needs. Upgrading to a high-efficiency model isn’t just about checking a box for a permit. It means you’ll use less energy to heat your water, leading to consistent savings on your gas or electric bill. It’s a practical improvement that adds real value to your home.
Proper Ventilation for Kitchens and Baths
Good ventilation is a non-negotiable for a healthy home, and Title 24 makes it a requirement. The standards ensure that exhaust fans in kitchens and bathrooms are powerful enough to effectively remove moisture and odors. This is about more than just getting rid of cooking smells or steam from the shower. Proper airflow is one of the best ways to maintain good indoor air quality and prevent mold and mildew from growing.
For your remodel, this means installing high-efficacy fans that are quiet yet effective. In the kitchen, a range hood that vents to the outside is often required. In the bathroom, a quiet, energy-efficient fan will keep the space fresh and dry, protecting your new tile, paint, and cabinetry from moisture damage for years to come.
What Happens If You Don’t Comply with Title 24?
Thinking about skipping Title 24 compliance to save a little time or money? It’s a tempting thought, but it can backfire in a big way. California’s energy code isn’t just a set of friendly suggestions; it’s a legal requirement for any major renovation. Ignoring these standards can turn your exciting home remodel into a frustrating and expensive ordeal filled with delays and unexpected costs.
The consequences of non-compliance ripple through every stage of your project, from the initial planning phase to the final sign-off. You could face issues with your local building department before a single wall comes down, or you might be forced to tear out and redo completed work after an inspection. These problems don’t just affect your budget; they can throw your entire project timeline off track, leaving you in a state of construction limbo. Understanding the risks upfront is the best way to ensure your remodel goes smoothly and results in a home that’s not only beautiful but also efficient and legally sound.
Permit Problems and Rejections
Before any construction begins, your project plans must be approved by your local building department. This is where non-compliance with Title 24 often brings a project to a screeching halt. If your plans don’t show that you’re meeting the required energy efficiency standards, your building permit application will likely be denied. This means your project is stalled before it even starts. The building department may also place your project under additional scrutiny, leading to more questions and requests for documentation. Getting your permit is the first major step, and failing to account for Title 24 can mean going back to the drawing board, which costs you both time and money.
Failed Inspections and Fines
Let’s say your plans get approved, but the actual work doesn’t meet Title 24 standards. During construction, a city inspector will visit your home to verify that the work matches the approved plans and meets all code requirements. If an inspector finds that your insulation, windows, or HVAC system isn’t compliant, you’ll fail the inspection. This often means you have to redo the work correctly, which can be a significant unexpected expense. On top of the cost of rework, you could also face fines from the city for the violation. These financial penalties are designed to discourage cutting corners and ensure all remodeling services create safe, efficient homes for California residents.
Setbacks to Your Project Timeline
Permit rejections and failed inspections create a domino effect of delays that can derail your entire project timeline. A permit denial can push your start date back by weeks or even months while you revise your plans. A failed inspection mid-project means all work might have to stop until the issue is fixed and re-inspected. These administrative delays and zoning conflicts can be incredibly disruptive, especially if you’ve planned your life around a specific completion date for your kitchen remodel. Recognizing these challenges early and planning for compliance from day one is the best way to minimize setbacks and keep your project moving forward smoothly.
How to Find a Title 24-Savvy Contractor
Finding a contractor who truly understands Title 24 is one of the most important steps in your remodeling journey. This isn’t just about hiring someone to build your vision; it’s about partnering with an expert who can guide you through California’s complex energy codes. The right contractor will make compliance feel seamless, while the wrong one can lead to frustrating delays and unexpected costs. To ensure your project goes smoothly, you need to know what to look for and what to ask.
Key Questions to Ask Your Contractor
When you first meet with a potential contractor, think of it as an interview. You want to gauge their expertise and proactive approach to Title 24. Recognizing challenges early allows you to prepare and minimize issues, so ask direct questions about their experience. Start with, “How do you stay current with Title 24 updates?” and “Can you share an example of a recent bathroom remodeling project where you handled compliance?” Also, ask them to identify potential hurdles for your specific project and how they would address them. Their answers will reveal how deeply they understand the regulations and whether they can anticipate problems before they start.
Check Their Credentials and Experience
Talk is one thing, but a proven track record is another. Non-compliance with Title 24 can lead to significant penalties and project delays, so it’s essential to verify a contractor’s qualifications. Start by checking their license with the California Contractors State License Board (CSLB). Look for certifications in green building or energy efficiency, as these show a commitment to the field. Don’t hesitate to ask for references from clients who have completed a major renovation. A confident, experienced contractor will be happy to provide them. Reviewing their portfolio can also give you a sense of their work and its quality.
Ask About Their Documentation Process
Title 24 compliance involves a lot of paperwork, and a disorganized contractor can quickly turn your project into a bureaucratic nightmare. A professional team will have a streamlined process for managing all necessary documentation. Ask them, “Who on your team handles the Title 24 compliance reports?” and “How do you document compliance throughout the project to prepare for inspections?” Understanding their workflow for submitting forms and managing quality control is key. A clear, organized process shows they are detail-oriented and equipped to handle the administrative side of your remodeling project, preventing permit issues down the line.
Helpful Resources for Title 24 Compliance
Getting a handle on Title 24 can feel like a big task, but you don’t have to do it alone. Plenty of excellent resources are available to help you, your designer, and your contractor make sure every detail of your project is up to code. From official state guides to specialized software and expert consultants, knowing where to look is the first step toward a smooth, compliant remodel that sails through the permit process. These resources can help demystify the requirements and give you confidence as you move forward with your project.
California Energy Commission (CEC) Guides
Your best bet for official information is to go straight to the source. The California Energy Commission is in charge of Title 24, and they offer a wealth of resources to help homeowners and contractors understand the rules. Their website on Building Energy Efficiency Standards is packed with compliance manuals, official forms, and approved software for different years. Think of it as the official rulebook for your project. While the material can be dense, it’s the ultimate authority on what’s required, making it an invaluable tool for ensuring your remodel is fully compliant from the start.
Helpful Software and Calculators
How do you prove your project meets Title 24’s energy-saving goals? It often comes down to a detailed report. Specialized software, approved by the California Energy Commission, is used to run calculations and generate the documents your local building department needs to see. For example, services like Title24EZ.com provide Title 24 reports and calculations to ensure that new construction, additions, and alterations meet California’s strict energy standards. These tools help translate your project plans into the specific data officials need to verify compliance, making the paperwork side of things much more manageable for your team.
Where to Find Professional Help
If reading compliance manuals isn’t your idea of a good time, you’re in luck. An entire industry of consultants and specialists exists to help builders, designers, and homeowners work through California’s energy codes. These experts live and breathe Title 24 and can answer specific questions about your project, from insulation values to HVAC sizing. They can run the necessary calculations and prepare your compliance reports for you. You can find answers on sites that offer Title 24 report frequently asked questions, which can be a great starting point. Ultimately, an experienced contractor will have these experts on speed dial.
Related Articles
- Home Remodeling in California: A Complete Cost Guide
- Home Remodeling CA: A Start-to-Finish Guide
- Frequently Asked Questions | Golden Heights Remodeling
- The Ultimate Guide to Remodeling San Francisco
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Title 24 apply to every single remodel, even small ones? Generally, yes. If your project requires a building permit, it will almost certainly need to comply with Title 24. This includes common projects like kitchen and bathroom remodels, window replacements, or updating your HVAC system. While a simple cosmetic update like painting or replacing a faucet won’t trigger these requirements, anything that alters your home’s energy-using systems or structure will fall under the code’s review.
Do I have to install solar panels on my house when I remodel my kitchen? Not usually. The solar mandate in Title 24 primarily applies to newly constructed homes and, in some cases, large additions like an ADU. A standard kitchen or bathroom remodel on an existing home typically does not require you to add a solar energy system. However, the rules are always evolving, so it’s a great question to ask your contractor at the start of your project.
Will meeting Title 24 requirements make my remodel more expensive? There can be higher upfront costs for some materials, like high-performance windows or a more efficient water heater. However, it’s best to view this as an investment rather than just an expense. These upgrades are designed to lower your monthly utility bills, so they pay for themselves over time through energy savings. A good contractor can help you find compliant options that fit within your overall budget.
Is there any flexibility in how I meet these energy standards? Yes, there is. The code offers two main paths for compliance: the prescriptive path and the performance path. The prescriptive path is like a simple checklist where you use specific, pre-approved materials and methods. The performance path is more customized, using energy modeling software to show that your unique design achieves the same overall energy savings, even if it uses different components. This flexibility allows for more creative freedom in your design.
What happens if my contractor messes up the Title 24 compliance? Ultimately, as the homeowner, you are responsible for your property meeting legal building codes. However, a reputable contractor takes on the professional responsibility of ensuring their work is compliant. If they make a mistake that leads to a failed inspection, they should be responsible for correcting the work at their own expense. This is why it’s so critical to vet your contractor thoroughly and have a clear contract that outlines their responsibilities regarding code compliance.